The Cookie

From Holiday Craving to a Tradition: Our Chocolate Chip Cookie Journey

What started as a simple holiday whim in 2012 has since evolved into a beloved tradition: our Chocolate Chip Cookie Experiment.

It all began over the holidays when we craved warm, freshly baked cookies paired with a cold glass of milk or steaming hot cocoa. We whipped up a batch on a whim—but the first few turned out far from perfect. They weren’t the best cookies we’d ever tasted, yet we happily devoured them anyway.

Undeterred, the next day I set out to master the recipe. To me, a great chocolate chip cookie isn’t just a dessert; it’s a delicate harmony of flavor and texture. I obsessively tweaked every element: balancing soft brown sugar against granulated, adjusting flour ratios, experimenting with different chocolates, and fine-tuning the percentages of cocoa butter and dark chocolate. I even accounted for oven temperature quirks, altitude, and heat distribution in our oven.

After countless trials, I finally nailed it—a cookie with a crisp, golden exterior that gives way to a soft, chewy center.

There was just one problem: each batch yielded far more cookies than we could possibly eat. Rather than let them go to waste, we started sharing them with friends and family, spreading the joy of these holiday treats we’d come to love baking.

And just like that, a delicious tradition was born: baking and gifting our perfected chocolate chip cookies every holiday season.